Everyone in the stadium could feel this one slipping away midway through the fourth quarter, but let's face it, YSU is a considerably better team. More sustained drives, big runs by their QB or catches by their receivers when they needed those plays to happen, better defense all around (including tighter coverage on our WRs than we could muster against theirs).
Basically, three gimmick play calls worked for us -- credit Shinnick there, and the execution -- and put us in position to win, but you need more than that against a quality team. As Mat has pointed out, we have next to no running game, and virtually none when Wooten gets the ball. Doss let the ball go through his hands on what should have been a first-down catch on our final possession, and let the defender wrestle the ball away from him on the long pass/INT. So, many missed opportunities, including the final play sequence on our opening drive.
We got hosed on the punt return holding penalty, but the roughing the passer flag on YSU that negated an INT was probably a bad call. In the end, we aren't good enough. Too bad, though. A win might have put some wind in our sails.
As a longtime fan, this game brought to mind painful memories, including Colgate kicking a FG on the final play to beat us back in our Patriot League era; William & Mary doing the same in the Sean Schaefer years; and going back further, Youngstown beating us in the Dave Meggett era when Chis Goetz throws an INT deep in YSU territory in the final minute and all we needed was a FG to win. Now that I think about it, we nearly knocked off the Penguins the year they won they national title (1991), Jim Tressel was their coach, Dan Crowley was our true freshman QB, and we held the lead for much of the game before folding late.