No objective analysis could conclude anything other than we’re mediocre, at best. This season is particularly disappointing given that there was a degree of momentum after going 7-5 last season, and being within a missed very make able FG of being 8-4. It’s hard to optimistic at this stage about the short term outlook. This is Shinnick’s 3rd season. By now, one would think he’d have his system & players fully in place. It looks like there will have to be almost a complete makeover for next season. That kind of roster shuffling is generally not conducive to on-field success, though perhaps this is the new normal, in the NIL era, even at our level. If I’m not mistaken, Nova, Richmond and W&M will all be ghosts next season, leaving the door open, ostensibly, for us to fill the void those departures create. I am not a Shinnick fan at all. I think the play calling is generally poor as well as the schemes on both sides of the ball. His recruiting is either lacking, or his ability to develop players is poor. Likely a combo of the two. If we play 2 FBS teams next season (Navy and I believe S. Carolina), our chances of making the playoffs are slim, as we’d have to go at least 8-2, if not 9-1, in our remaining games, unless we somehow get the AQ by winning the conference.
Attendance is mediocre, which is not surprising considering the product on the field. This board is a microcosm of the apathy surrounding the football program. On the post game thread regarding yesterday’s game, I believe only 4 posters (Mat, myself, sr16 and 2012) even bothered to post. If I left anyone out, I apologize. Add to all this that we’re in a conference which is a shell of what it once was, replacing the likes of JMU, DE, W&M, Nova and Richmond with NCAT, Hampton, Bryant, Campbell and Sacred Heart. Although DE didn’t view us as their rival, we viewed them as such, and generally won enough games vs them for it to be considered a rivalry (it’s not a rivalry if 1 team wins all the time). Now, we’re on an island, with no semblance of a rivalry. We’re too far north of the southern bloc (Campbell, Hampton, NCAT, Elon…) and too far south of the northern bloc (URI, Maine, UNH ….)
With all this being said, Shinnick isn’t going anywhere, so the best we can hope for is that the watered down conference provides us a path to dominance. I personally doubt that this will come to fruition, but I guess we have to cling to this idea